Extensis melds two popular type managers into one: evolved application or FrankenTypeManager?

Once upon a time, in the land of Macintosh OS X, there were two stalwart guides who provided the typographically inclined effective font management in the new and confusing geography of the Macintosh OS X file system. The were known far and wide as Sir Suitcase and Sir FontReserve, and they served their constituencies well. Their patrons, Queen DiamondSoft and King Extensis of the West, charged them well, and they competed but still coexisted.
Then, in a royal wedding, King Extensis acquired the employ of Sir FontReserve. For a while, they still coexisted, but under the suzeranity of the good King; eventually, the King Decreed that Sir Suitcase needed to grow. A period of retraining of our good knight obtained perforce; and the result has a new, bigger shinier Sir Fusion. Sir FontReserve still has much work to do as ambassador to the land of Wintel, but Sir Fusion aims to champion the interests of both FontReserve and Suitcase partisans in the land of Macintosh.
Can the good knight succeed in his new mission? Read on, MacDuff, read on…
Extensis itself raises a good point; why go pro? After all, modern Mac OS X from Panther forward offers Font Book, a basic font organization and managment tool. It allows one to organize fonts in sets, quickly install and uninstall fonts, offers previews, and gives basic information about installed fonts on one’s Macintosh.
It is notable, however, for the lack of certain features pro users value (and savvy amateur users could make use of: gathering and consolidation of font files, efficient libraries, activation by face, and direct control of system fonts amongst other things. And the interface provides basic information, which may be good but might not be enough. This is the gap that Suitcase and Font Reserve have filled.
Since Extensis acquired Font Reserve from DiamondSoft, development for both applications continued to version 10 for Suitcase (Suitcase X1) and version 3.1 for Font Reserve. Presumably it was seen that each user base could benefit from features each other’s applications had but both did not offer. Therefore, Suitcase Fusion.
First, my cards on the table: I am a long time Suitcase user. I have always enjoyed the Suitcase interface, the ease of setting up and activating sets for temporary use, and the quick and customizable previews. And, with OS X’s different places for stashing fonts depending on system, user, or users, what’s not to like about having quick access to information and previewing in one place along with automatic activation for my favorite applications?
Fans of Sir Suitcase will be encouraged by the interface. There was no major redesign; the interface is the same familiar face shown by Suitcase X1, with an obviously new feature: the “Keywords” button is gone in favor of an “Attributes” button. Clicking this opens a drawer with a list of predefined font classifications; double-clicking any one will filter out a list of the appropriate fonts in the font list pane.
Setting up sets uses the same method familiar to Suitcase users, Suitcase Fusion now also includes the ability to set up nested sets as well as application-specific sets.
Both Suitcase and Font Reserve users will see benefits to the new program. Suitcase users get font identification and database enhancements never before known to them; the huge amount of information available to the user and to the applications that depend on Suitcase Fusion; technologies such as Font Sense provide integrity and uniqueness to each font so that when an application or document calls for a certain font, the original font used is the one activated, preventing text reflow problems.
Font Reservists will get the benefit of a customizable interface and precise, customizable previews. All users will benefit from the innovative Font Vault, a centralized repository that is meant to eliminate font conflicts and assure overall integrity thoughout the system, as well the overall flexibility to use the program to any level they wish; fonts can be put in the vault or not, system fonts can be managed or not, original fonts can be left in place, and the user can stick with their own font management scheme or let Suitcase Fusion do it all.
We have had a copy of Suitcase Fusion on our desktop for a couple of weeks now, giving it the go around. In the beginning, I mentioned on how I have used Suitcase X1 for while now; Suitcase Fusion give the same ease of use that I had with X1, with the addition of new information available quickly. I like organizing my own fonts using Suitcase Fusion as my access point; it’s an improvement that’s transparent.
The idea of the new font organizing capabilities, nested folders and application-specific sets, strike me as something I can certainly make use of. Suitcase Fusion runs well and with no problems to speak of; it’s a tool I can see myself depending on.
Unlike Font Reserve, Suitcase Fusion must stay active to manage fonts. This may be a weakness to some, but it fits my personal workflow style just fine.
Suitcase Fusion is intended as an upgrade product for Suitcase X1 and Font Reserve 3.1 Macintosh users (Font Reserve is still maintained as a separate product for the Wintel crowd). Extensis has a long history of producing useful tools and it shows; for Macintosh users, Suitcase Fusion gives font wranglers the best of both worlds in one tight program. If it’s time for the partisans of Font Reserve and Suitcase to unite, Suitcase Fusion ought to do the job.
By The Numbers:


I had been using Linotype FontExplorer X for several months without issue. Though it’s still a beta, it’s free and works VERY well. But there were a few annoying features about it that were enough to make me at least **try** Fusion.
After using Fusion for about a week now, I’ve already had one “headache.” Fusion simply refused to open. I deleted the font vault file in my Library and re-imported all my fonts again. This time I made a backup copy of the FontVault file in case it happens again.
That aside, it works pretty good. It’s fast, and most importantly for me, VERY ACCURATE when auto-activating. Also, being able to activate a single font face, rather than the entire font is a god-send - especially when trying to resolve duplicate fonts, etc..
If you’re a Suitcase or Font Reserve users, I highly recommend the upgrade.
You brought up a very powerful feature here. Font Vault can be backed up and saved in case something gets corrupted. If a user chooses to import all thier fonts into the Vault they it looks as though they can save thier entire font library off disk and replace it if something goes wrong with it. I was also very impressed by that.
DESIGNORATI
I had to uninstall Suitcase Fusion ASAP. It was a true nightmare. Literally hours and hours to do what Linotype FontExplorer X does in SECONDS. In other words, if you’re a masochist who enjoys perpetually reading “Application Not Responding”, you’re gonna love Suitcase Fusion.
I kid you not, it regularly took hours to respond to an activation of a group of about 20 meager fonts. The only solution Extensis offers to these ridiculous wait times in their manual is just don’t force quit the app as it can lead to serious problems. O-k-a-y.
But, this is not the end of my tale. I idiotically trusted Extensis to manage my system fonts. I noticed immediately that some of the fonts in a few of my applications (ie, Apple Mail…the number indicators by the folders) were a bit wonky. But this was heaven compared to what was just around the corner.
Long story short: “Startup disk is full” message.
After hours of panic and attempting to isolate what was caused my startup disk to fill to capacity, I found the culprit. A 10 GB ‘asl.log’ full of the same error message over and over again from another piece of software that couldn’t access the system font it needed to operate. Thanks again, Extensis!
It was at this point that I began shining up my boots to drop kick Suitcase out of my life forever. Can you say AppZapper?
Anyway, I wasted a little more time deleting the 10 GB asl.log file and disabled the app that was seeking the font that Extensis was monkeying with, then spent a full day reinstalling and reorganizing 2700 fonts — after waiting over half a day beforehand for Suitcase Fusion to allow me to even access them (can you say, “Application Not Responding”?).
Thankfully, the FREE Linotype FontExplorer X was there to help me pick up the pieces from what seemed an eternity in Suitcase Fusion Hell.
Anyway, the silver lining to this story is that I discovered that FontExplorer X is a genuine breeze to use. Quick, responsive, and pretty to look at. Did I say QUICK? Yes!
Oh wait! Not so fast. It appears that when Suitcase ‘managed my system fonts’ it altered several of them.
The original Helvitica and Times system fonts (in the /System/Library/Fonts folder):
HelveLTMM
Helvetica LT MM
Helvetica.dfont
Times LT MM
Times.dfont
TimesLTMM
… were apparently subdivided further by Extensis to include the following:
Helvetica_bold.dfont
Times_bold.dfont
Times_italic.dfont
Times_bold_italic.dfont
So, when you move your system fonts back to their PROPER place (which is, incidentally, NOT in Extensis’ file vault… apparently so secure even the system can’t access it), be sure when you’re doublechecking the relocated fonts in the ‘/System/Library/Fonts’ folder against Apple’s default installed font list, make sure that these 4 additional fonts (that Extensis has so nicely made for you) are there. (Why can’t Extensis just put the ORIGINALS back where they’re supposed to be?)
Apple’s List (notice the 4 fonts mentioned are NOT on it): http://docs.info.app...e.html?artnum=301332
Anyway, all is back to normal now (I hope). It remains to be seen whether the four mutated fonts above will introduce any further havoc. We’ll see…
Why on earth would anyone use the crap shoveled out to graphic designers by extensis when linotypes FontExplorer X is free? Not only is it free but its the best font management program ever made, period. I manage over 6,000 fonts and FontExplorer X has NEVER let me down, ever.